I've read through this whole thread and I didn't want to say anything but for what it's worth, I agree with Casey. Instead of bickering back and forth online (b/c I think many people have made valid points advocating both sides), why not just give it a shot 1 round... if it doesn't pan out, hey at least we tried.

I think ultimately this will help the club bring excitement back as a whole (not this specific example necessarily), trying new ideas, testing a couple things out and seeing what the members think. Even if something is sort of ridiculous but the members love it and it makes the day just that much more entertaining, if it really is a "no harm, no foul" type situation then why not let it stick?

Just my 2cents... carry on.