PDA

View Full Version : Proposed rule in for sale section?



303 cycle
March 24th, 2014, 01:05 PM
I'm a member of the LSGTO forum and they have a couple rules for posting in the for sale section of their site. I thought this would be useful for the MRA to set as a standard. I believe this would make clear post on the seller's behave and would prevent a lot of back an fourth questions that could be answered with a detail sale post.

Mainly you have to have a Price, an actual picture of your item for sale (this shows the item YOU have in your possession), etc.

I've attached thier rules below:


Please note that violation of these rules carry consequences varying from deletion of your thread to loss of posting privileges on the forum.

1. YOU NEED (50) POSTS TO CREATE A FOR SALE THREAD.
It's a simple rule, and it's enforced by the forum software. You must have (100) posts under your account before you're able to create a thread in the For Sale sections of the forum. Postwhoring to (100) posts is strictly prohibited. If you're caught postwhoring through the forum to get to the required minimum, your For Sale thread will be deleted and your post count lowered to zero. There are many, many members here, and have no doubt that even if a member of the moderation staff misses your postwhoring, they will - and they will rat you out. Postwhoring is the act of making useless posts like "cool paint" or "nice numbers" in threads in order to just get your post count above 100.2. 'GAUGING INTEREST' IS 'FOR SALE.'
If you post a thread in this forum, you're offering your item(s) for sale. 'GI' or 'Gauging Interest' does nothing to change the requirements for posting in the For Sale sections.3. PRICE YOUR ITEM(S).
This is not eBay. You must post a price of all item(s) when you post your thread. 'OBO' is alright, and is understood to mean that you may accept offers lower than your asking price. Your asking price, of course, is not a 'starting point,' and auction-style selling is strictly forbidden here.4. NO PICS, NO THREAD.
This rule has been a controversial one for some. Effective January 15th, 2008, any threads found without pictures have been deleted on sight. This 'zero-tolerance' policy regarding pics will continue for the foreseeable future, so warm up those digital cameras. To be clear, pics are required of the actual item(s) you are selling. If you are selling multiples of the same part, then we need to see a picture of every one. It is neither sufficient nor clever to post stock images from the Internet or images of items 'similar' to the ones you are selling. It is not the responsibility of the moderation team to show you how to post images, attach images using the forum software, or to provide you with a means for hosting your images. Such responsibilities are yours and yours alone. While it is alright to post a link to your images - perhaps an FQuick.com photo album - if the link becomes dead, your thread is then in violation of the rule and is subject to deletion.

A couple of notes. First and foremost, a picture of your item is required at the time you post your thread. Secondly - and this is a lesson lost on too many people for inexplicable reasons - the purpose of this rule is not to let us see what the item looks like. "I'd post pics, but I think we all know what these look like" is asinine. Yes, we probably know what 18" stock wheels look like. But we don't know what your 18" stock wheels look like, so post 'em up.

Finally, pics in your avatar and/or signature do not count. If you got the pics into your signature, you can get the pics into your post. Signatures and avatars are often changed without any regard to previous posts made in reference to them, so at any time, your FS thread can be left in violation of the posted For Sale Rules. Besides, many members have Signatures and/or Avatars turned off in their User Control Panels. Please post your pics in the original post.

Effective January 30, 2009, all pictures must contain a piece of paper with the seller's username and a date written clearly and legibly. If we can't read it, it isn't there. If the username and date is not clearly visible in the photo, the thread will be deleted on sight.

Update reguarding "Cars For Sale"
When selling a car, make sure that the detail shots, interior, engine bay ect, contain a sigcard (Screen name and date written clearly on a piece of paper). It would be nice to see the card/paper leaning against a wheel or tire in a wide shot and then an additional shot of that wheel showing the card/readable. If the sigcard shows up in the detail shots, it is pretty obvious that the car is in the sellers possession at the time of the shoot. Wide shots (full car shots) are excluded from needing a sigcard. There must be details shots, with sigcards, in the post.5. NO THREADCRAPPING.
A seller's asking price is never "too high." The price of an item is between the seller and the buyer; if you're not the buyer, do not post in the thread expressing your displeasure with the seller's asking price. This rule is Infraction-worthy. If you threadcrap, you can earn a one-point Infraction. Remember that Infractions have an expiration date, but if you earn 10 points, you get a week-long suspension from the forum.6. 'PM SENT,' 'BTT,' 'TTT,' ETC.
Excessive bumping of a thread is frowned upon, as it takes away from the visibility of other threads. Keep your 'Bumps,' 'BTTs,' 'TTTs,' etc. to one per day. Only the seller is permitted to post 'Bump,' 'BTT,' 'TTT,' etc. Sellers, note that replying to questions in your own thread counts. 'PM Sent' is a useless post. If you sent the seller a PM, you do not need to announce it in the seller's thread. The moderation team can and will randomly delete 'PM Sent' posts.8. GARAGE SALE.
Please try to post multiple items in one thread. Do not inundate the forum with a thread for each item you are attempting to sell. One or two threads may be permitted, but more than that may be merged into one thread.9. NO 'POSTING FOR A FRIEND.'
Please be aware that buying and selling between anonymous parties via the Internet is risky business. You literally put your reputation on the line every time to buy or sell an item via the Internet, and when you post an item or items for sale "for a friend," you're still putting your reputation on the line, not theirs. If the item(s) are in your possession, and the pics that you post of the item(s) have been taken by you, and you broker the deal entirely, then I suppose there's no harm done. However, there is to be no "posting this for a friend" threads. If you're not taking responsibility for receipt of funds and/or shipment of product, please refrain from posting the thread.10. NO LINKS TO OTHER SITES
Links to other sites where the items are for sale are not allowed. This also goes for posting Ebay links in your threads. The items must solely be for sale here on this forum only.11. PAYPAL PAYMENT CHARGES
Per the PayPal End user agreement you may not add a percentage or fee to use PayPal. Price your item accordingly.
Posts that state you will be assessing PayPal fees will be removed/deleted.
https://www.paypal.com/us/webapps/mp...agreement-full (https://www.paypal.com/us/webapps/mpp/ua/useragreement-full)
4.6 No Surcharges. You agree that you will not impose a surcharge or any other fee for accepting PayPal as a payment method. You may charge a handling fee in connection with the sale of goods or services, as long as the handling fee does not operate as a surcharge and is not higher than the handling fee you charge for non-PayPal transactions.
Per the PayPal End user agreement, you may not ask for payment as a gift.
4.1 Receiving Personal Payments. If you are selling goods or services, you may not ask the buyer to send you a Personal Payment for the purchase. If you do so, PayPal may remove your ability to accept Personal Payments.
8.1 Fees Overview.

Fees are based on whether you are making a Purchase Payment, a Personal Payment or a PayPal Business Payment. Some fees are expressed as a percentage of the payment amount. All Fees are in U.S. Dollars unless otherwise stated.

a. For Purchase Payments, the recipient of the payment will always pay the Fee.
These rules are always subject to change, and while we appreciate your input, the moderation teams actions are at their discretion. If you take umbrage with an action by any member of the moderation team, you are encouraged to send a private message to the administration team with your questions, comments, or concerns.

jplracing
March 24th, 2014, 02:20 PM
Unfortunately, a lot of internet forums have gone down this road. I fully realize the reasons for making these kind of rules (ie stop spam, create revenue etc...).

However, I am not seeing the reason we should allow this on our forum.

One, we don't have a problem with spam and/or scam postings. So why solve a problem we don't have

Two, this forum is primarily used by local members and racers that would like to race with us. Since our main goal is too attract fellow racers, why would we want to limit them in any way?

Three, racing is expensive enough. Why would we want to charge our members for a service that should be free?

Louden
March 24th, 2014, 02:56 PM
Agreed, Why fix a problem we don't have.

303 cycle
March 25th, 2014, 08:43 AM
Be proactive, just because you haven't had a problem doesn't mean there won't be one.

I guess I should have edited it a little more but the main thing I was looking at was clear pictures, etc. I've also seen a number of 1st post in the for sale section by people not in the MRA. I believe some modification would be need to suit the MRA but I think adding a few simple rules in the for sale section would be benificial.

Whats your interpretation of "lightly Used" or "slight Rash"?

Its an idea to prevent spam, hold people accountable for the items they are selling, etc. Its really aimed at protecting members of the MRA. This is especially important for new members who maybe looking for items to start their racing career with the MRA.

There is no "fee" basically if you say I have "XXX" and I want $350, they buyer pays $350 with paypal fees included. Meaning the seller gets to eat the 3% charge.

TRK
March 25th, 2014, 10:03 AM
If we are lucky we get one or two posts a day in the classified sections. Not sure what we are trying to fix....

303 cycle
March 25th, 2014, 11:19 AM
Ok, perhaps this needs a visual comparison to get my point across.

50% of the For Sale post are like this

Thread: Tire warmers for sale

I have a set of used Chick Hawk pole position tire warmers. PM or email me

Under a simple new rule format that could be "stickied" at the top of the for sale section

Thread: Chicken Hawk Racing Tire warmers - Red Pole Position lightly used

I have a set of used Chicken Hawk Pole Position tire warmers. Used for one track day about 4 hours. These are the single temp model and retail for $399.95. MRA price is $220 shipped or $210 for local pick up. I can be reached via PM or by email davidstryingtosellhisshitontheMRA@gmail.com

http://i712.photobucket.com/albums/ww125/303cycle/20140325_110904.jpg (http://s712.photobucket.com/user/303cycle/media/20140325_110904.jpg.html)

Basically right now there are no rules. I'm proposing a simple change that sellers simply make complete listings to the benifit of potential MRA buyers
1. Picture
2. Price
3. Description
4. Maybe a miniumum post limit? I've seen more than a couple for sale adds with non-MRA members and 1 or 2 post.
5. No links to youe ebay/craigslist add - take the time to make a specific MRA add

rforsythe
March 25th, 2014, 12:12 PM
So when we implemented some similar rules on CSC, it was to address a problem of the unknown one-post-wonders coming on to hawk their shit, and the occasional spammer being stupid. At least on that forum, the for sale area is meant to be a free resource to that club/community in particular, so we just put in a simple post count minimum (15 I think) which the software enforces. If someone's seen whoring just to be able to sell stuff, it's dealt with. That is a rare occurrence though, particularly now that we have more robust human verification to even get a legit account. That same verification also exists on the MRA forum now FYI, thanks to Spiderman. That has dramatically cut down and generally eliminated the script-bots that come on to post BS.

We didn't require pictures there; generally people just have better luck selling stuff when they show what it looks like. It's not our job to enforce compelling advertising practices. Contact info helps, but you can always reach someone through the forum's PM or email functions, so it's not strictly required in the post (and we actually advise against posting email addresses or phone numbers in public like that for obvious reasons). I actually don't care if they post a CL or eBay ad link if that's where they've put the time to write it all out. Granted it's not terribly time consuming to copy/paste somewhere else and will be a better ad if the details don't require extra effort to attain, but again - not our problem.

I think there is a fine line between being too draconian and setting some kind of bar in the interest of "keeping it in the community". Since this area does get frequented by out-of-state racers who might not otherwise be in the MRA, but are still part of the racing community-at-large, it's kind of hard to say that they must engage with other people here before they can sell something of interest. I do agree that these types of rules serve a purpose and in many cases are even necessary, but just haven't seen the need on this particular forum either.

If it's ever deemed necessary, the post count minimum takes 10 seconds to set up. The rest is just a moderator administrative thing.

303 cycle
March 25th, 2014, 12:16 PM
^^There we go Ralph

I'm not trying to create a extra hard way of selling. Just a couple mimimum standards when selling items in the For Sale Section.

rybo
March 25th, 2014, 01:57 PM
David -

I'll take the warmers. Thanks for the informative advertising!

-rybo

rforsythe
March 25th, 2014, 02:31 PM
David -

I'll take the warmers. Thanks for the informative advertising!

-rybo

Was it the picture that sealed the deal for you?

Did you send a PM about it? You're supposed to tell us all when you send a PM, you know.

TTT.

rybo
March 25th, 2014, 02:37 PM
Email didn't work.

PM sent

rforsythe
March 25th, 2014, 02:49 PM
I think that price is too high, personally. I bet he's charging a PayPal service fee...


TTT!